West Bay Shore, NY 172 Apartments for Rent with Garages

Enjoy an affordable living experience in the sought-after Bay Shore neighborhood, where the rent is notably below the metro average. The property features spacious rooms with charming hardwood floors and convenient parking. Its strategic location offers ease of access to local amenities.

This charming apartment is located in the highly sought-after neighborhood of Deer Park, offering an attractive price below the metro average. The property features bright and spacious living with hardwood floors and large bedrooms, making it an ideal choice for those seeking comfort and value. Even without immediate proximity to popular points of interest, its location in a desirable area makes it an appealing option.

50 The Crescent offers a 12% price advantage below the metro average. Located in the popular Babylon neighborhood, this vintage 2-bedroom apartment is conveniently close to the town and train. Enjoy the charming updates like a new kitchen while being pet-friendly with cats allowed.

23 Jacqueline Way is beautifully located in North Babylon's popular neighborhood, making it a sought-after locale for renters. Enjoy a spacious two-bedroom unit equipped with in-unit laundry and granite counters, complemented by a lovely patio or balcony. These amenities add to the charm of living in a dynamic area.

Situated in a popular Islip neighborhood, 55 Saint Marks Lane offers a charming setting for a spacious lifestyle. This sprawling ranch house features delightful amenities such as a cozy fireplace, hardwood floors, and modern kitchen appliances. With a fenced yard and deck, it is perfect for relaxing outdoor living.

This property is located in a highly sought-after neighborhood in Bay Shore. It offers a spacious two-bedroom condo with a fully fenced corner lot. Modern amenities like a dishwasher, in-unit laundry, and refrigerator add to its appeal.

106 Park Avenue sits in the popular Babylon neighborhood, known for its lively atmosphere and accessible village amenities. The property features a newly renovated kitchen with modern appliances, hardwood floors, and convenient in-unit laundry. Residents enjoy the enclosed porch and easy access to village pool and docking areas.

Situated in Bay Shore, this apartment offers an excellent value at 12% below the metro average. Located in a popular neighborhood, it provides a blend of quality living with in-unit laundry and walk-in closets. Perfect for those who seek cost-effective living with convenient amenities.

27 Newbrook Lane is situated in Bay Shore, a popular neighborhood that offers a vibrant lifestyle. The property features essential amenities like in-unit laundry, walk-in closets, and internet access. It's a perfect fit for those seeking convenience and modern living.

This property is situated in the vibrant and popular Bay Shore neighborhood, offering a prime location for convenience and community appeal. Residents enjoy in-unit laundry and dedicated parking. A short drive connects you to various local amenities and adventures.

Situated in the desirable Babylon neighborhood, this property offers fantastic local charm. Residents enjoy convenient access to community features, amplified by its prime location. The apartment itself provides an excellent appearance with essential amenities like parking.

Easily enjoy the affordability of this charming property, attractively priced below the metro average while nestled in the popular West Babylon neighborhood. It offers a beautiful renovated kitchen and ample natural light. With utilities included, this home is a great choice for budget-conscious renters.

12 Brandt Court is located in the highly desirable neighborhood of Bay Shore, offering the perfect balance of tranquility and convenience. This spacious duplex features beautiful hardwood floors throughout, an updated kitchen and bath, and a fully finished basement with a laundry hookup. The property is also recently renovated, enhancing its appeal to those seeking modern living spaces.

262 E Main Street boasts a prime location in the desirable Babylon neighborhood. Residents will enjoy being within walking distance to a variety of restaurants and bars, making it perfect for those who love city living. The property also offers parking, adding convenience to its array of local delights.

This charming 2-bedroom rental is nestled in the highly desirable Baywood neighborhood, offering a cozy living room and a private driveway for easy parking. Ideal for those seeking both comfort and convenience, the property provides exclusive access to a backyard for leisure activities. Located conveniently close to highways, it ensures a seamless commute and access to local amenities.