West Bay Shore, NY 172 Apartments for Rent with Garages

Nestled in the popular neighborhood of Ocean Beach, this Fire Island gem offers luxury living at an astonishing 50% below the metro average price. Enjoy spacious accommodation with four bedrooms and two baths, perfect for hosting guests. Modern amenities like in-unit laundry and a fully equipped kitchen make this home ideal for a comfortable seaside lifestyle.

Nestled within the popular Ocean Beach neighborhood, this property offers a significant cost advantage, priced 44% below the metro average. It's an ideal spot for beach lovers, offering proximity to the shoreline and ample space with three bedrooms. Additional amenities like a dishwasher and in unit laundry enhance its appeal.

This property is priced significantly below the metro average, making it an attractive option for those looking for value on the beautiful Fire Island. With stunning bay views and a new pergola area perfect for entertaining, it is a luxurious retreat. The home is equipped with modern conveniences like air conditioning, in-unit laundry, and a dishwasher.

790 Surf Road offers an affordable escape, priced significantly below the metro average, making it a cost-effective choice for potential renters. This contemporary and spacious home is filled with light and equipped with modern amenities like a dishwasher, in-unit laundry, and parking options including a garage. Residents can also enjoy convenient features such as an outside shower, bicycles, and beach essentials, enhancing their living experience.

61 Ocean Road is nestled in the sought-after Ocean Beach neighborhood, known for its charming seaside appeal. Situated just seven houses from the beach, this property offers convenience and luxury with amenities like a heated pool, hot tub, and a wood-burning stove. Enjoy modern comforts and leisurely activities with features including air conditioning, in-unit laundry, and bikes for scenic rides.

This property offers cost savings with pricing below the metro average. Situated in the sought-after Ocean Beach neighborhood, it promises both convenience and charm. The home comes with premium amenities including a pool and in-unit laundry to enhance your living experience.

This property is nestled in the sought-after Ocean Beach neighborhood, offering a 25% savings compared to the metro average. Newly built with two primary bedrooms, it boasts views of the bay, a lovely pool, and additional convenience with amenities like in-unit laundry and a garage. Proximity to popular local attractions and refined features such as a wine fridge and outdoor shower enhance its appeal.

Nestled on Fire Island, 30 Gale Walk offers a charming cottage experience with modern comforts. The property is equipped with desirable amenities such as a dishwasher, in-unit laundry, and a private deck, providing a comprehensive and cozy living environment. Experience the peaceful atmosphere of Fire Island in this lovely home, perfect for summer getaways.

Located in the sought-after Ocean Beach neighborhood, this charming home offers a serene retreat close to the beach. Enjoy modern conveniences with in-unit laundry, a dishwasher, and accessible features. Bask in beachside living with a lovely deck and outdoor shower.

Enjoy a perfect summer getaway at 44 E Bayview Avenue. This cozy two-bedroom apartment comes with a private deck and a garage. Its appealing features make it an excellent choice for a seasonal retreat, offering everything needed for a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

32 Kelp Avenue on Fire Island offers cost savings with rent significantly below the metro average. This family-friendly home is perfect for gathering, featuring 5 bedrooms and accommodating 10. The property boasts amenities like in-unit laundry and a garage, enhancing convenience and comfort.

Located in Ocean Beach, 833 Evergreen Walk offers significant affordability at 16% below the metro average, ideal for value-conscious renters. Situated in a popular neighborhood, this newly renovated property features spacious living areas with a fabulous screened-in porch. Amenities include a private deck with a hot tub and convenience-enhancing features like in-unit laundry and a garage.

49 Surf offers a remarkable 33% cost saving compared to the metro average, making it an affordable option on Fire Island. Ideal for large families, this spacious property comfortably accommodates up to 12 people. Among its features are modern conveniences such as a dishwasher, in-unit laundry, and a garage, adding significant value to its attractive pricing.

Located in the popular Ocean Beach neighborhood, this property is priced significantly below the metro average, offering great value for renters. Enjoy modern comfort with amenities like a dishwasher, in-unit laundry, and a spacious deck. The property is perfect for those seeking a blend of value and desirable location.

Nestled in the desirable Ocean Beach neighborhood, this property offers exceptional affordability, being priced significantly below the metro average. Its recent renovations include modern amenities like in-unit laundry and a spacious porch, perfect for entertaining. This vacation-ready home is also equipped with beach accessories making it ideal for family getaways.

142 Bungalow offers a highly attractive rental price, boasting a 19% savings below the metro area average. Situated in the charming and popular Ocean Beach neighborhood, this beach house is perfect for those seeking a serene coastal lifestyle. Noteworthy amenities include a newly renovated interior, in-unit laundry, and convenient parking options.